*GASP!!!* A proper post from Manda! Can it be?!
I'm going to TRY to come out of hiding. I'm not sure that going IN to hiding was really a conscious choice or not in the first place. Part of it is something I do periodically in a completely non-fandom related way. Part of it is that I haven't had the ability to concentrate on doing any one thing long enough lately to finish it - ie, even writing an LJ post.
In either case, I intend upon writing more frequently from now on, if I can make myself.
I saw BeruBara / Exciter yesterday, as well as attended Mame-chan's (Hinata San) ochakai. This was my first live show in practically two months, believe it or not. Buying a $1000 plane ticket home for the holidays DOES have the annoying tendency to take a chunk out of your kangeki budget. I attended Tomu's ochakai for Gyakuten Saiban 2 last month, but wasn't able to see it.
So.... BeruBara. BeruBara, BeruBara, BeruBara. What can I say about it? I think Tegan summed it up pretty well yesterday:
The revue (Exciter) was worth the entire 2000 yen for touji B seki.
BeruBara was full of fail. Epic fail. BeruBara is this tricky beast; You go in expecting certain things in regards to a BeruBara show. Yet, at the same time, you don't really expect groundbreaking, earth-shattering theatre. You expect small things like the ridiculous 10 or 15 minute prologue and a ludicrous amount of melodrama. You expect overacting
BeruBara is okay in moderation and when you know what to expect. There's this guilt in watching it where you realize it's pretty damned ridiculous and you want to roll your eyes at the melodrama, but it's OKAY to secretly be liking something so ridiculous.
In this Andre Gaiden.... you just feel.. unsatisfied. It feels wrong. There's no melodrama. Everyone looks tired (
wao_wao, I rode home on the train with one of my club members last night and she said the exact thing about them looking tired too). They've spliced down the top musumeyaku's role to practically nothing, all while sticking her in a rather hideous dress (Ayane-chan fans, may your fears be allayed in that she has some AMAZING dresses in the revue half, including a red slitted number with full-leg visibility). There's ridiculous inconsistencies. Sou's Alain coming across rather... stoned. Fersen's dialog, when faced with Oscar's feelings. Wow... HARSH.
And they inserted the Andre x Oscar confession scene.... only to mutilate it. I wonder how that conversation went in the universe of Ueda-sensei's head: "I have the AMAZING idea! Let's stick in the confession scene! But let's move it outside to the garden! And then COMPLETELY CHANGE THE DIALOG where we'll say that OSCAR KNEW ALL ALONG"
Frustration.
Bringing this gaiden back to the Daigekijou gave them the opportunity to rework it, to improve upon what were supposedly obvious problems with it the first time around. Instead.... it's....I don't know even how to put the disappointment into words. While speaking with another Japanese fan, the only way she could describe it was "ダメ"
Okay, my attention and concentration is waning quickly so I'll have to write about
Exciter! later. Suffice it to say, it's the only part of the show WORTH the full price of admission.